So you're saying that it never gnawed at your conscience that you had to reject someone you really liked in the past (even recent past), simply because when they admitted they did want to try a relationship you were already in another one?
To me this happened 2 or 3 times in my life, and all of those times it kept gnawing to my conscience for a couple of weeks to a few months (depending on how hard my crush on them was) in the same way as is happening with Josy. Trust me, it isn't a nice feeling and can haunt you for quite a while, especially if you're still good friends with them.
No, never what gives that impression? Because I'm pretty sure it's not the fact that I hang out in a AVN forum
Anyways my overall point with all of this was that being honest with Sage doesn't necesarry mean telling her everything especially if it's something that could hurt her. For example: In ALL playthroughs Jade flashes MC her pussy right next to her husband. How does the MC even
BEGIN to tell her that and how would that not just hurt her and her (already) poor impression of her family?
FuckFace: "Hey Jade so your mom flashed me her vagina once when we were at your father's office discussing Chad assaulting me. I just wanted to be honest with you and I think you deserve to know

Oh by the way, your dad and Jill where in the room too"
Telling Sage her mother is a complete mess of a whore or that his boyfriend's EX still has unresolved feelings for him wouldn't help her at all that was my argument xD