Meh, still at the early parts of the update, but the MC is still a bipolar mess. One moment he wants to make Madison his obedient plaything, next moment he is a soyboy who is guilty about groping Olivia, then he is a hopeless romantic with the dream girl, then he is a stuttering virgin around Natalie.
edit: Then MC goes all dark in the car after picking "Who cares?" "Who cares how they feel? What matters is what I want!" Right after that, he sees Madison and Allison and self monologues that he is feeling bad about Olivia and that he needs to spend more time with these two to show them that he cares.
edit2: And then he decides that he will be a sadist with Maddie. He threatens her that her punishment is not over. And then we go right back to the "normal" relationship dynamic where she is kind of snippy and uppity and the MC is a caring father. Then we choose the dark option when shes showering and the MC acts like a fucking child by punching the door to give her a shock and then runs away going "kekeke."
edit3: This goes on even within a single scene. Brooke BJ, similar conversations leading up to it. Then all of a sudden, bam~ dark mode. "Suck that cock slut." "Oh, why is he being mean...?" A few lines of that and we go right back to the same script that plays for the romance route. MC becomes a simp again and Brooke is all lovey dovey.
I'm sure this will keep on going in this way. The game is almost unplayable on the dark path because of this. The game doesn't take nearly enough care in the script to support the route. Usually, we get a clearly "dark" conversation or thought right after picking a dark choice. Once in a blue moon, the game calls on the variable to alter a line or 2. But everywhere else, it uses the same script that is used on a good route when it clearly doesn't make much sense. I know with 100% certainty where the game is using the normal script and where the game used the "dark" version. It usually just goes from 0 to 100 and back to 0 all the time. This has been so since the very first version and it looks like it won't ever change.
Some consistency in his personality would be nice.