It may be that RK Studios added this particularly creative story twist because of a personal experience, or for creativity purposes, or maybe for those of us who play these games for really diverse story and more than just a quick fap...I mean if we just wanted to jerk off there is exorbitantly more than enough porn out there...fitting a plethora of styles and fetishes...to get our rocks off without having to work our way through a detailed story gameplay to get it. An example being, As you pointed out, there is lots of hentai that fit your particular fetish...some of which also have good stories, but don't require the gameplay and choice directing. Besides, the MC had a hymen breaking deflowering with the triplets mother at the beginning of the game...and will likely have 3 more with the triplets...so the Brooke twist adds variety that keeps the game from overplaying 1 trope while still offering a similar option. That's just good writing in my book. And if the player doesn't like it they always have the option of not perusing Brooke as a LI at all and just keep it professional with her.
Oh I'm not asking for a change at all, just expressing my utter confusion at the inclusion of this plot point.
I feel like this plot point was included for the Virginal/defloration fetishists', which as someone who is one, this is way off the mark, at least for me.
The plus side of a girl being a virgin is the tightness and (for some) the idea that you're taking her purity. The plus side of having a milf is you get an experienced woman who knows what she's doing and how to please a man.
For Brooke, she has none of the good qualities of either, that tightness is already gone and probably had her hymen taken by the invitro device by the doc. Anyone who's fucked a woman both before and after childbirth knows it doesn't feel the same, so she'll be looser. Brooke also admittedly has no experience with men so doesn't know what she's doing.
Its like we get the worst qualities of both a milf and a virgin here, doesn't know what she's doing, and will feel loose due to childbirth. xD
So I don't get the reason for this plot point? Why the need to make Brooke a technical virgin when all the benefits of her being a virgin are gone? Could easily of just said she had a one night stand or failed relationship previously and been fine. I mean, we already have 3 virgins in the triplets + Gracie (one can only pray they still have hymens like their mother.)
I still like the game, just confused by the need for the mental gymnastics.
Ahahahahaha, yup, this right here is the only reason I could see for the need for this virgin/invitro shenanigans.
I just don't get how the "Holy Virgin" myth type thing could be sexy, and this is coming from someone who finds virgins sexy, lol.