But yes, I agree with you. Nothing in her family, physical and emotional situation justifies that all the other girls in the game are attracted like a magnet.
I wouldn't say realistic though, this game sometimes still has vibes of being a porn game, like how everyone magically expresses interest in our protagonist, are you telling me that the hot women in his college only has one type?
Don't confuse being kind and friendly with attraction.
Just like the smile of a waitress doesn't mean anything.
Besides a few obvious cases (Mila, Vic, Nami, Nia.) the other girls are more or less just friendly.
Nobody's asking him out or is trying to get into his pants.
And the penis locker room talk... well, that's just locker room talk.
What is currently drawing people to the MC is curiosity. If you and Bella are a thing, be sure that it will not go unnoticed and people will be curious who this guy with the incredibly perfect hair is.
It's the same with the Robin/Sasha gym scene in Ch3. You only get invited if you're good with Bella.
It's not necessarily the MC, it's the circumstances that surround him.
there's really no reason for mila and victoria to be so into our protagonist.
Mila does mention that she picked interest in him because he doesn't act like the others. (In the gym route she says that she's surprised that he hasn't even looked at her cleavage once. This picked her curiosity.
Victoria shares a traumatizing event with the MC. That's more than enough to make people feel like having a connection.
Mila (Mc's anti-sexual behavior.)
Vic (Shares a traumatizing event with the MC.)
Nami (The past.)
Nia (Besides the fact that she likes the way he looks, there's some background here, too.)
I sincerely hope the Tabletop session won't be just excuse to have sex scenes because that's generally the point of DND in these games.
No need to worry.
I'm not building up a slow burn connection to ruin it with something as cheap as a "Dream scene" or "Fantasy scene."
That's also the reason why Sonya is still wearing her Hijab in the tabletop session.
It's much more than just a piece of clothing. It's a mindset.