Kodek

Well-Known Member
Jun 26, 2017
1,139
1,362
No the Cheat sheet was in the toilet, the Male toilet in fact, so again another hole in the Sally theory, probably a hole in any of the cheaters being girls
Also here, cohaboring evidence that not only the bathroom is for both M and F, it's also just for the students in that room.
screenshot0022.png
 

osculim

Well-Known Member
Aug 21, 2019
1,463
1,260
No the Cheat sheet was in the toilet, the Male toilet in fact, so again another hole in the Sally theory, probably a hole in any of the cheaters being girls
That does not stop anyone from entering. Perfect cover for a girl. Oh it was found in the Guys bathroom. Must be a guy. That is sexist :ROFLMAO:
 

Yellowie The Goldie

Active Member
May 8, 2022
546
529
1. The cheat sheet had a shitload of tests, not just the one MC did.
2. It's normal that for exams classes are mixed up from their usual groups.

I'm not saying Sally IS the cheater, just why she couldn't be ruled out because she wasn't in MC's class.
It's not Sally, she's the furthest from the suspects. She takes medically prescripted drugs and is apparently able to speak Latin. It's likely that she is simply an average grade student. She shows affinity for learning and understanding due to MC tutoring her in his room, so she's clearly not stupid or a bad academic.

There's not enough reason to suspect her to be cheating while she is at the same time buying drugs to help with academic learning.
 

Chillout1984

Engaged Member
Nov 15, 2020
3,161
1,942
It's not Sally, she's the furthest from the suspects. She takes medically prescripted drugs and is apparently able to speak Latin. It's likely that she is simply an average grade student. She shows affinity for learning and understanding due to MC tutoring her in his room, so she's clearly not stupid or a bad academic.

There's not enough reason to suspect her to be cheating while she is at the same time buying drugs to help with academic learning.
I agree. Like I said before, to me Gina is still the most likely suspect to be Anderson.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yellowie The Goldie

Kodek

Well-Known Member
Jun 26, 2017
1,139
1,362
Does not mean there was just one exam. Usually here when one group leaves another group takes the exam.
From where I am, exams happen at the same time. Plus, there was not a lot of students taking intro in math or english anyways, a lot of them were not going into the actual lessons like Gina, but I don't think it would need multiple classes.
 

osculim

Well-Known Member
Aug 21, 2019
1,463
1,260
It's not Sally, she's the furthest from the suspects. She takes medically prescripted drugs and is apparently able to speak Latin. It's likely that she is simply an average grade student. She shows affinity for learning and understanding due to MC tutoring her in his room, so she's clearly not stupid or a bad academic.

There's not enough reason to suspect her to be cheating while she is at the same time buying drugs to help with academic learning.
There is more than enough reason to suspect her of cheating. She is clearly not doing well and as I said earlier she had access to all those cheats before to give the impression that she is actually smart. She is my contender for the cheater.
 

osculim

Well-Known Member
Aug 21, 2019
1,463
1,260
From where I am, exams happen at the same time. Plus, there was not a lot of students taking intro in math or english anyways, a lot of them were not going into the actual lessons like Gina, but I don't think it would need multiple classes.
There is more than one exam per subject. If you look throughout the game how many times have you seen those background characters that are never in your classes. They also have to write exams. We need to realize its not just the characters we interact with that goes to this college.
 

Yellowie The Goldie

Active Member
May 8, 2022
546
529
There is more than enough reason to suspect her of cheating. She is clearly not doing well and as I said earlier she had access to all those cheats before to give the impression that she is actually smart. She is my contender for the cheater.
That doesn't mean anything since Ron himself is also in the same boat during Episode 8 "Maybe I just accepted that I'm a B- at best?" to which Magnar replies with "That's the most ignorant thing I've heard today."

You're reaching for something that's not there dude. There's no evidence to support she's cheating with tests instead of drugs.
 

Kodek

Well-Known Member
Jun 26, 2017
1,139
1,362
There is more than enough reason to suspect her of cheating. She is clearly not doing well and as I said earlier she had access to all those cheats before to give the impression that she is actually smart. She is my contender for the cheater.
What cheats she had acess? Notes are not cheats. There's literally NO evidence of her being the cheater.
And there's a lot of reasons for her not doing well and be struggling, main one being stress and her mental problems. She is getting more meds for anxiety and depression and she also can be the mole of the nerds and she is also at every party in the game. All of this would make she struggle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yellowie The Goldie

Lagunavii

Well-Known Member
Oct 11, 2023
1,743
1,778
The Thing is you are not going to be able to simply walk into an exam hall with your cheat sheet ready to hide. that shit would have needed to be placed well ahead of time. And I know from my time at school/College and University. there were times that there were students queuing up outside waiting to go in as I was leaving.

The script actually says "mc "Yeah, I'm sure! I took a good look at those papers. They had the answers to many questions and plenty more on top of that." so while it had answers to many questions on the MCs exam, it had more on top of that... we don't actually know if the sheet was designed to be used specifically for MCs exam. it could have been for one earlier in the day or later in the day.
 

Kodek

Well-Known Member
Jun 26, 2017
1,139
1,362
There is more than one exam per subject. If you look throughout the game how many times have you seen those background characters that are never in your classes. They also have to write exams. We need to realize its not just the characters we interact with that goes to this college.
From game evidence ALL the students take the exams together, regardless of year or subject. And there's 0 problem with background characters no going to your classes because, as you said, it's not just the characters we interact that goes to this college. Why would all the characters go to the same class?
 

osculim

Well-Known Member
Aug 21, 2019
1,463
1,260
That doesn't mean anything since Ron himself is also in the same boat during Episode 8 "Maybe I just accepted that I'm a B- at best?" to which Magnar replies with "That's the most ignorant thing I've heard today."

You're reaching for something that's not there dude. There's no evidence to support she's cheating with tests instead of drugs.
Well there is no reason for lilly to cheat. There is no evidence for her and neither is there for Ashley. Its way more likey for Sally to be the cheater. None of the other two had those opportunities Sally had. The only reach here is if you think its Ashley or Lilly. But yeah we can agree to disagree. Time will tell. Hopefully not in another 10 episodes.
 

Kodek

Well-Known Member
Jun 26, 2017
1,139
1,362
The Thing is you are not going to be able to simply walk into an exam hall with your cheat sheet ready to hide. that shit would have needed to be placed well ahead of time. And I know from my time at school/College and University. there were times that there were students queuing up outside waiting to go in as I was leaving.

The script actually says "mc "Yeah, I'm sure! I took a good look at those papers. They had the answers to many questions and plenty more on top of that." so while it had answers to many questions on the MCs exam, it had more on top of that... we don't actually know if the sheet was designed to be used specifically for MCs exam. it could have been for one earlier in the day or later in the day.
So that student that cheated NEEDS to go at the MC's class. That's the point. That's the whole point. It does not matter the other tests, the cheater HAD to be taking the same exam as the MC, it does not matter if they cheated more or less classes.

Heck, they could've been taking multiple more classes on top of the intro ones.
 

osculim

Well-Known Member
Aug 21, 2019
1,463
1,260
What cheats she had acess? Notes are not cheats. There's literally NO evidence of her being the cheater.
And there's a lot of reasons for her not doing well and be struggling, main one being stress and her mental problems. She is getting more meds for anxiety and depression and she also can be the mole of the nerds and she is also at every party in the game. All of this would make she struggle.
The same cheats you bought from Magnar. She had access to them from ep1
 

Kodek

Well-Known Member
Jun 26, 2017
1,139
1,362
Well there is no reason for lilly to cheat. There is no evidence for her and neither is there for Ashley. Its way more likey for Sally to be the cheater. None of the other two had those opportunities Sally had. The only reach here is if you think its Ashley or Lilly. But yeah we can agree to disagree. Time will tell. Hopefully not in another 10 episodes.
Sally was not taking the the test with the MC and the rest of the people from Math and English intro how the fuck is she the cheater here?! Why would the cheats have answers for a test she was not even taking? And why Ashley be me reaching? We have no evidence that Ashley is actually a good student apart from Bella saying she is top of her class which would be easily explained if she was a cheater.
 
4.70 star(s) 1,637 Votes