Okay, maybe I shouldn't jump into this conversation since I don't really like arguing and all. But I'm genuinely curious here. What's wrong with these examples? Honestly, I don't understand.
What's the problem with MC taking on the role of a white knight and trying to stand up for a colleague? Is it bad? Oh no, a man stood up for a woman he doesn't know well. How terrible! This never happens in normal stories, right? And he doesn't have his own place to live. So that means he should keep quiet? Is that the logic? And what's with the criticism about having two bags of belongings? When I was 20, that's all I had too. As I imagine many guys that age do.
The conversation example is a bit more complex. I admit I'm not a native English speaker, so maybe I'm missing something. Of course, the example given is significantly simplified, but here's the full version:
lu "Mom says you're living the dream. That you finally escaped our backwater and found your place."
lu "But Dad's a whole different story. Keeps muttering that you'll be back any day now. Thinks the big city's too much for you."
mc "(As if he ever believed in me.)"
lu "Don't listen to him. A couple more years, and I'll be right there with you, showing this city what we're made of. We've always had each other's backs, remember?"
mc "Of course I remember. We're a team! You and me against the world."
mc "(I forgot how much I missed this little troublemaker.)"
mc "I miss you, sis. This city wouldn't be so lonely if you were here. Every adventure's more fun with you around."
lu "Don't worry. I'll be there soon. Hang in there till then. I believe in you."
lu "Everything's good with you, right? Mom's really worried, you know."
mc "I won't lie, Lucy, it's not easy. But I'll find my way, I promise."
Yes, maybe there should have been some kind of pause before "Everything's good with you, right? Mom's really worried, you know." But is it really that unnatural?
I won't deny I have plenty of issues with story construction, characters, etc. But these specific examples... I don't know. Is this criticism just for the sake of criticism, or am I really missing something? I'm asking because I'm genuinely interested. I always try to improve my understanding of how to write a story.