I just hope patching things up with Natalie doesn't revolve around giving her a good dicking.
Sure, have it as a route gate but don't use it as a story mechanic.
She's thot hot, sure, but with three girls and Brooke I feel like the MC just won't have enough time for everyone.
I've already kicked Vanessa to the curb because her unconscionably rude behaviour during the date-but-not-date-but-is-date with Brooke.
Analysing the three mains, I have this:
Liv is kind and generous but seems to be emotionally volatile.
Allie is an airhead with seemingly overlarge -for her frame- breasts. (Refer to "sleepwalking" scene)
Maddie is what I can best describe as a Tsundere. If she had her way, we wouldn't even have a game. Hot, though.